Hotel life.

This week Elizabeth Bowen took me to the Italian Riviera. It was 1927. There, I watched a group of seasoned travellers fritter their lives away in aimless drifting.

The start of the story had promise.

Miss Fitzgerald hurried out of the Hotel into the road. Here she stood still, looking purposelessly up and down in the blinding sunshine and picking at the fingers of her gloves. She was frightened by an interior quietness and by the thought that she had for once in her life stopped thinking and might never begin again.

I was prepared to like Miss Fitzgerald. All kinds of situations were possible. I rarely read the blurb on the back cover. It’s usually either wrong, or gives away key moments. So I had no expectations.

Inside the hotel, Miss Pym responds to the same situation.

She, after a short blank pause of astonishment up in her room, had begun to creep down the stairs warily. She listened; she clung to the banisters – tense for retreat at every turn of the staircase.

Something momentous has happened. Miss Fitzgerald has made a ‘violent exit’ from Miss Pym. She has said something terrible, ‘discharged with such bitterness of finality‘. The phrasing hints at secrets shared in trust, and weaponized in moments of crisis.

What I admire about Bowen is her economy. She moves the story forwards and backwards at the same time.

‘At this crisis of ungovernable agitation Emily (how well they knew each other!) would have taken to the hills. Miss Pym could see plainly her figure stumbling up in the glare towards the shade of the olive-trees, breast to breast with the increasing slope. She must be given a little longer to get away.

If only we could have stayed with these two women. By the second page, though, Mrs Kerr enters. She ‘stood beautifully, balanced either for advance or immobility‘. Who is she? What is she? It’s hard to say.

Though she is a focus of the attention of most characters, we’re not allowed access to her thoughts. Occasionally she tells someone about her emotions, but I’m not sure I always believe her.

Her profile did not commit her: it expressed an ironic indulgence to fashion in the line of a hat-brim, the soft undulation of hair, an earring’s pendulous twinkle, the melting suave lines of a scarf round the throat. Mrs Kerr took fashion in and subdued it and remained herself.

That’s as close as we get. I read on because I trust Bowen. She’d presented me with a group of repressed Brits sharing bathrooms, dining rooms and tennis in a sultry foreign landscape, surely something must break.

Theo Champion (1887 – 1952)

There were moments when I was interested. Passion is suggested and characters behave badly. There was comedy and some farce. But the truth is, I didn’t care. I tried to, but I began to feel that really, Bowen didn’t want that.

The guests at the Italian Villa mostly kept mannered distances from me, as well as each other, even in moments of tension. In our previous meetings, Elizabeth Bowen’s been a wonderful hostess. She’s introduced fascinating people, who’ve shared their joys and heartbreaks, and I’ve been sorry to reach the last pages of their stories.

I began to question whether this disconnect was a problem with me. Was I meant to be so conscious that these characters have too much money and luxury? A lot of literature produced up to this point in the twentieth century focused on the rich and privileged, and I don’t usually complain about it.

There was one exchange that offered an alternative explanation. On a rainy afternoon, as Joan, one of three pretty sisters, is writing a letter, Colonel Duperrier, who is a little younger than her father, starts a conversation about one of the few eligible young men in the hotel.

‘Can’t young Ammering get a job?’

‘No he can’t,’ Joan said defensively. ‘It worries him awfully. The War’s come very hard indeed on our generation. I don’t think people understand a bit.’

‘Perhaps they don’t,’ said Colonel Duperrier, who had also fought.

‘We have to make allowances for ourselves,’ continued Joan. ‘You see, nobody makes them for us. I know young people are always supposed to be fearfully idealistic and that sort of thing, but I suppose we can’t help feeling that, considering how hard things are on us, we aren’t really so bad.’

Perhaps, then, the novel intended me to feel uncomfortable. In this 1927 view life has not changed for the better, for the privileged at any rate. There is an emptiness at the heart of their comfortable lives. Behaviour, sex, class, marriage, careers and education all come under the spotlight.

I stuck it out to the end of the novel, and I’m glad to have read it. But it’s not one I’ll be keeping.

18 thoughts on “Hotel life.

  1. Very interesting to know how it begins. I am fond of Bowen’s short stories and would expect to like a novel too – but it’s a different fish. I see you’re glad you read to the end and now I am both intrigued to start this novel and wary of finding it a trial.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. My curiosity was aroused by your comment that you rarely read the blurbs on the covers of books. I’ve had many experiences where the blurb has over inflated the book (Transcription by Kate Atkinson was the latest) but if you don’t read them how do you decide whether the book is one you want to read?

    Liked by 2 people

    • I’m a sucker for titles. I frequently pick something up just because the combination of words draw me. If I’ve doubts, I dip in, first the opening line, then a couple of sentences from the middle.

      I also follow recommendations. Blogs like yours are great. I’ve a list of titles-to-look-out-for in the back of my diary, and it’s been drawn mostly from recommendations I’ve read.


      • That’s a good strategy – I do look at the blurbs for phrases that I detest (like “their lives were changed forever …”. But I do also look at the first few sentences. Never thought about looking in the middle too. What a good idea though

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Thought provoking…haven’t read the novels, only the short stories….some tell a similar story. ‘Oh,Madam’ stands out for me…and one other I can’t remember the title of, but am going to dig out and re-read, thanks to this prompt!

    Liked by 2 people

    • I think you’ve pinned my problem with them. Those ‘bright young things’ were so determinedly alienating, and Bowen successfully conveyed that. I also had a problem with the ethos of the whole social group, which seemed to have no purpose but to drift from destination to destination. It’s certainly not a novel I’d recommend as a starting place for reading Elizabeth Bowen.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Hmmm. I have a feeling this sort of novel would have annoyed Younger Me (no explosions or murder? Boo!), but now I also think it would annoy present me more for the…how’d you put it…the characters who have too much money and luxury. I like reading characters who are driven, you know? Ones with purpose. And my impression from your post here is that these are folks without purpose. That also sounds like that’s their problem to overcome, but….eh, I don’t think I could care about that.
    I care about your post, though! Always fun to read your analyses. 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks, Jean.
      When I sat down to write this post it was going to be a negative review. Only, as I began to think about what I wanted to say I began to speculate about what Bowen had done. If I’m right, it makes for a very clever novel. My problem remains, though, and it’s exactly the one you pin-point, the characters are mostly passive. Maybe it worked better when it was first published, in 1927.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh indeed. There’s something to be said for the societal context of a novel. Daniel Eggars’ THE CIRCLE is another good one–it speaks to us who fear technology’s invasion into our lives *now*, but I wonder if the novel will still connect to readers after another ten years of drones, social media, and even more sharing online.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s