Film review: Official Secrets.

‘Are you sure you want to watch this one?’ Ray said. ‘I mean, what about a film where we don’t know the outcome?’

I said, ‘But look at the cast list, Keira Knightly, Matt Smith, Rhys Ifans, Ralph Fiennes, Tamsin Grieg… it’s a who’s who of British talent. Can they all be wrong?’

Ray shrugged, ‘It’s your choice.’

‘We can watch another, if you like. You choose.’

‘No, no,’ he said. ‘Official Secrets it is. I just can’t see how it’s going to be entertaining to watch when we know that it ends with a war. I mean where’s the story?’

‘That’s what I’m curious about,’ I said.

I turned off the light, pulled the curtains on the torrents of summer rain pouring down the window, and Ray hit ‘play’.

A courtroom, paneled in dark wood, with Kenneth Cranham high up on the bench in his wig and gowns, was the grim face of British justice. Keira Knightly walked nervously up from the cells and into the dock to be faced with that eternal question, ‘How do you plead, guilty or not guilty?’

There was a pause. The camera panned closer to her face. What did it say? Which way would she jump? All I could read was apprehension.

Then the opening titles came up.

‘Did she do it, though?’ Ray said.

I couldn’t remember much. I vaguely recalled some of the lead-up to the trial, the headlines and the furore. But there had been so much anger, back then, so much heated debate, everywhere. I’d even witnessed it surging over into classrooms where I’d had to improvise ways to divert it into something creative.

‘We’ll just have to let it all unfold,’ I said, as the story flashbacked to 2003. That’s what we did.

There was nothing lazy about the way the story was delivered. It began with some brief orientation scenes when Ray and I played do-we-recognise-that-location, because these events began not far from our own doorstep.

Soon we were inside one of the most secret buildings in the country. As we number friends and neighbours who do or have worked there, but say nothing about it, this was also fascinating, even if fictional.

Katharine Gun’s dilemma was the first email she opened. We knew that she was going to end up in court, charged with breaking the official secrets act, and yet, the film kept both of us gripped. This was not about action, it looked at motivation, and not just Katharine’s.

Equally fascinating were the discussions about her email release in the newspaper office, and amongst the legal teams. Characters argued with conviction for each side of the debates that led up to the invasion of Iraq by British and American forces, and from a variety of stand-points.

In a way, watching with the knowledge that Katharine’s actions would not achieve their intended actions, added to the tension. It was not the story Ray had dreaded, a predictable rehashing of recent events. There may not have been guns, car crashes or bloody action, but there was drama.

It was personal, and believable. Strengths and weaknesses of arguments and motives were explored. We saw, close up, how actions impacted on relationships.

At the end, I found myself thinking about the way we understand events, and wondering about the kinds of impressions we store in our memories. In retrospect, I could see how important this story had been, yet I’d remembered so little of it. Only as I watched did I realise I’d conflated a couple of similar cases with this one.

No doubt, a contra version of this story could be told. That is, after all, the way history should be written.

It may be that I liked this film so much because I it reflected my own sympathies. What this fiction of true events, this docu-drama, did for me, was to make me think about justice, and how lazily I accept the winning version of where and how it is presented.

Even if there was a clear slant to this version, back then, at the times of the document leak, and the trials, my view of Katharine had almost certainly been tainted by powerful voices on the mirror side of this story.

Official Secrets is a film I want to watch again, soon. In part, for the convincing characters, but also because it was about me. I’ve been left asking the question, ‘how would I respond to a similar test?’

43 thoughts on “Film review: Official Secrets.

  1. I want to see it. And as for knowing the ending – well that doesn’t stop the eternal appeal of WW2 movies.

    And the idea reminds me that as young person I would re-read “The Diary of Anne Frank” with the hopeful idea that maybe this time it would end differently. Daft., I know.

    Liked by 4 people

  2. I really want to watch this film. I saw a trailer for it last year and I was both gripped by the story and attracted by that great cast you mention. We almost saw it at the cinema back in early March, but there’d been a burst pipe or something and the cinemas was closed. And then, of course, there was Covid… I’ll definitely catch it when I can.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. I saw this at the cinema and had forgotten how good it is. I thought the cast were utterly believable, and like you it made me question the way I believe to readily the one side of the story I’m being given. Great review!

    Liked by 3 people

    • I confess that I’ve only seen a few scenes from Titanic, so I can’t offer to make a comparison. I’ll only say that this one wasn’t in any way what I expected the story to be.

      Like

  4. Hadn’t heard about it before, but it sounds intense. So I asked Mr. G. and Mrs. Wiki gave me the premise. A lot of books give you the ending first then the story, and I think it all comes down to presentation. If the ending gives me an itchy case of the curious… the itchier, the better 😉 Even if I knew how the story went, but I found the concept fascinating, I think I’d like to know how they’d put it together and present it – and we’ve circled back to my point.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Thank you, Zoemayb.
      Most of the images I use are taken from paintings and images that are old enough to be copyright free. In the case of this post, and others linked to films, I’ve used publicity stills. I’ve also used photos we’ve taken, and occasionally, drawn my own. Recently, I’ve looked at Pexels Free Photos, which you can find when click on ‘Upload an image’. Good luck. I look forwards to seeing your blog-posts.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s